Kugel warm from the oven. Walks to the library hand-in-hand with my mother past Silverod’s Pharmacy where she might buy me a candy bar.
Forget those fantasies. That’s not the Jewish mother I had, not like some of the others I saw all around me when I was growing up in Brooklyn. I walked to the library on my own. On the coldest winter days, she pushed me out the door during blizzards and I was one of the few who showed up on the days when New York City schools were canceled. I trudged home down deserted streets clutching the chocolate Devil Dog I bought from the deli across the street from my school.
Years later, in a classic reverse migration she moved from Miami to Baltimore in her late 70s settling in just in time for our caretaking roles to switch. Still I was hopeful that she might become a traditional Jewish grandmother. Everyone should get a second chance.
My kids loved her attention and we had our rituals, especially our Mother’s Day brunch at the Museum Café. She would split one big sundae with my kids when they were young enough to share but they shared little with my mother as they grew older and her attention wandered.
On a Mother’s Day when she became too ill to go out to brunch, we visited her in the nursing home, and the nurses and aides there that day told me she was a favorite. “She adopted us all.” Who was this woman, I wondered.
This is our second Mother’s Day without her. The second year I won’t be dragging my kids and myself to visit and we won’t be wondering when it’s time to go. I know now she wasn’t the Jewish mother I wanted but I still wish I had somewhere to go.

